Best overall 3Commas alternative: WunderTrading (WhichBot score 9.8/10): DCA, Grid and TradingView signal bots like 3Commas, a lifetime free plan, 20 exchanges and no incidents on record. Best for grid bots: Bitsgap (free plan, 17 exchanges). Cheapest: Pionex (no subscription, 0.05% per trade, but custodial) or WunderTrading (lifetime free plan, paid from $15/mo). Most strategy control: Cryptohopper. No-code rules: Coinrule.
3Commas for reference: Starter $20/mo, 15 exchanges, WhichBot score 7.4/10. 3Commas vs Cryptohopper · 3Commas vs Pionex · 3Commas review
Every field re-checked on the vendor's own pricing or feature page on the date shown. "Not published" means the vendor doesn't state it publicly.
| WunderTrading | Bitsgap | Cryptohopper | Pionex | Coinrule | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WhichBot score | 9.8 how? | 9.3 how? | 7.8 how? | 7.8 how? | 9.1 how? |
| Price tiers (monthly / annual) | Free $0 · Basic $15/mo · Pro $37/mo · Premium $75/mo As listed; annual billing up to 25% offchecked 2026-11-02 · source | Free $0 · Basic $29/mo · Advanced $69/mo · Pro $149/mo Annual: $23 / $55 / $119 per month (−20%)checked 2026-11-02 · source | Explorer $29/mo · Adventurer $69/mo · Hero $129/mo Annual: $24.16 / $57.50 / $107.50 per month (−17%)checked 2026-11-02 · source | No subscription: built-in bots are free to runchecked 2026-11-02 · source | Free · Investor $29.99/mo · Trader $59.99/mo · Pro $675/mo Annual: $265.99/yr Investor, $532.99/yr Traderchecked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Free plan or trial | Lifetime free plan plus a 7-day Pro trial; no card neededchecked 2026-11-02 · source | Free plan (manual trading + demo bots) and a 7-day PRO trial, no card requiredchecked 2026-11-02 · source | 3-day free trial of Explorer on sign-upchecked 2026-11-02 · source | Yes: bots are free; you only pay trading fees. Demo trading availablechecked 2026-11-02 · source | Free plan (paper trading)checked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Fees beyond subscription | None on exchanges you connect; Hyperliquid route is free Premium with a 0.035% builder fee per tradechecked 2026-11-02 · source | No per-trade fee listed; charges processed in USDchecked 2026-11-02 · source | Prices exclude VAT. Copy Bot is a separate $9.99–$99.99/mochecked 2026-11-02 · source | Spot 0.05% maker / 0.05% taker · Futures 0.02% maker / 0.05% taker · Leveraged tokens 0.10%checked 2026-11-02 · source | Credits over the monthly allowance billed at $0.02 eachchecked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Exchanges | 20 Binance, BingX, Bitfinex, Bitget, BitMEX, BloFin, Bybit, Coinbase, Coinex, Crypto.com, Deribit, dYdX, Gate, Hyperliquid, Kraken, KuCoin, MEXC, OKX, Phemex, WOO Xchecked 2026-11-02 · source | 17 Aster, Binance, Binance US, Bitfinex, Bitget, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Evedex, Gate, Gemini, HTX, Hyperliquid, Kraken, KuCoin, OKX, Poloniex, WhiteBITchecked 2026-11-02 · source | 11 Binance, Binance US, BingX, BitMart, Bitvavo, Coinbase Advanced, Crypto.com, HTX, Kraken, KuCoin, OKXchecked 2026-11-02 · source | 1 Pionex itself (bots run on its own exchange; no outside exchanges)checked 2026-11-02 · source | 15 Alpaca, Binance, Bitget, Bybit, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Gate, Gemini, HTX, Hyperliquid, Kraken, KuCoin, MEXC, OKX, Webullchecked 2026-10-29 · source |
| Bot types | Signal (TradingView), DCA, Grid, Market Neutral, Multi-Pair Grid, AI bot; spreads & arbitragechecked 2026-11-02 · source | Grid, DCA, LOOP, BTD, COMBO (futures), QFL; futures bots from Advanced; AI Assistantchecked 2026-11-02 · source | Trading, DCA, Copy, Manual/Portfolio bots; Market Making & Arbitrage and AI strategies on Hero onlychecked 2026-11-02 · source | Spot grid, futures grid, copy bot (others are listed in the app; not all on the public pages)checked 2026-11-02 · source | If-this-then-that rules, 350+ templates, backtesting, AI agentschecked 2026-10-29 · source |
| Custody | Non-custodial: trade-only API keys, withdrawals must be offchecked 2026-11-02 · source | Non-custodial (exchange API keys)checked 2026-11-02 · source | Non-custodial (exchange API keys)checked 2026-11-02 · source | Custodial: Pionex holds your fundschecked 2026-11-02 · source | Non-custodial (exchange API keys)checked 2026-10-30 · source |
| Known security incidents | none knownchecked 2026-10-30 · details | none knownchecked 2026-10-30 · details | 1 incidentschecked 2026-10-30 · details | none knownchecked 2026-10-30 · details | none knownchecked 2026-10-30 · details |
| Visit WunderTrading | Visit Bitsgap | Visit Cryptohopper | Visit Pionex | Visit Coinrule |
Affiliate disclosure: links to Cryptohopper, Bitsgap, WunderTrading, Coinrule, TradersPost and TradingView are affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no cost to you. 3Commas and Pionex links are plain links (no affiliate deal). Commissions never change scores or verdicts.
TradingView alerts can drive WunderTrading. Get TradingView: new users who sign up through our link get a $15 coupon toward their next plan after their first purchase.
For most people, WunderTrading: it's non-custodial like 3Commas, has the same DCA, Grid and TradingView signal bots, a lifetime free plan, 20 exchanges and no security incidents on record. Bitsgap is the best pick for grid bots, with a free plan and 17 exchanges.
Yes. Pionex bots have no subscription (you pay 0.05% trading fees, and Pionex holds your funds). WunderTrading and Bitsgap have $0 plans, and Coinrule has a free paper-trading plan.
Price and trust are the common reasons. 3Commas confirmed a leak of users' exchange API keys in December 2022. Its plans run $20–$140 a month.
WunderTrading is built around TradingView signal bots. TradersPost does the same for stocks, options and futures.
$20, $50 or $140 a month for Starter, Pro and Expert, or $15, $38 and $105 a month billed annually, with a free trial.
Trading bots can lose money. WhichBot scores rate safety, custody, price and coverage, not profits. How we score.
New features, new exchanges and price moves across 20 AI trading bots, every Friday. Free.
No spam. WhichBot is a directory, not investment advice. We never touch your funds or API keys.
Affiliate disclosure: some links may be affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Bots never pay for placement or score. Not financial advice: trading bots can lose money. Data last checked 2026-11-02; each field shows its own check date.