Pick Pionex if you want grid bots for free and don't mind keeping your coins on Pionex itself: there's no subscription, you pay 0.05% per spot trade. Pick 3Commas if you want your funds to stay on your own exchange (15 supported) and need DCA, Signal and TradingView automation, starting at $20 a month. It's custody vs cost: Pionex holds your funds; 3Commas doesn't, but leaked users' API keys in 2022.
Every field re-checked on the vendor's own pricing or feature page on the date shown. "Not published" means the vendor doesn't state it publicly.
| 3Commas | Pionex | |
|---|---|---|
| WhichBot score | 7.4 how? | 7.8 how? |
| Price tiers (monthly / annual) | Starter $20/mo · Pro $50/mo · Expert $140/mo Annual: $15 / $38 / $105 per monthchecked 2026-11-02 · source | No subscription: built-in bots are free to runchecked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Free plan or trial | Free trial on every plan (length not published on the pricing page); demo account on all planschecked 2026-11-02 · source | Yes: bots are free; you only pay trading fees. Demo trading availablechecked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Fees beyond subscription | No per-trade fee listed; you pay your exchange's trading feeschecked 2026-11-02 · source | Spot 0.05% maker / 0.05% taker · Futures 0.02% maker / 0.05% taker · Leveraged tokens 0.10%checked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Exchanges | 15 Binance, Binance TR, Binance US, Bitfinex, Bitget, BitMEX, Bitstamp, Bybit, Coinbase Advanced, Gate, Gemini, HTX, Kraken, KuCoin, OKX Bitget is futures-onlychecked 2026-11-02 · source | 1 Pionex itself (bots run on its own exchange; no outside exchanges)checked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Bot types | DCA, Grid, Signal bots, SmartTrade, Pine Script® and webhook execution, API (Expert)checked 2026-11-02 · source | Spot grid, futures grid, copy bot (others are listed in the app; not all on the public pages)checked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Custody | Non-custodial (exchange API keys)checked 2026-11-02 · source | Custodial: Pionex holds your fundschecked 2026-11-02 · source |
| Known security incidents | 2 incidentschecked 2026-10-30 · details | none knownchecked 2026-10-30 · details |
| Visit 3Commas | Visit Pionex |
Affiliate disclosure: links to Cryptohopper, Bitsgap, WunderTrading, Coinrule, TradersPost and TradingView are affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no cost to you. 3Commas and Pionex links are plain links (no affiliate deal). Commissions never change scores or verdicts.
Running Pionex's built-in bots has no subscription. You pay Pionex's trading fees: 0.05% maker and taker on spot, 0.02% maker / 0.05% taker on futures, per its fee page.
Roughly when a bot trades more than about $40,000 a month: 0.05% of $40,000 is $20, the price of 3Commas Starter. Your exchange's own fees still apply on 3Commas, so compare those too.
Yes. Pionex is an exchange, so bots trade with funds you deposit there. 3Commas is non-custodial and trades through API keys on your own exchange.
No. Pionex bots only run on Pionex. 3Commas, Bitsgap and Cryptohopper connect to outside exchanges like Binance.
Pionex has less setup: no keys and no plan to choose. 3Commas has a demo account and more control.
Trading bots can lose money. WhichBot scores rate safety, custody, price and coverage, not profits. How we score.
New features, new exchanges and price moves across 20 AI trading bots, every Friday. Free.
No spam. WhichBot is a directory, not investment advice. We never touch your funds or API keys.
Affiliate disclosure: some links may be affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Bots never pay for placement or score. Not financial advice: trading bots can lose money. Data last checked 2026-11-02; each field shows its own check date.